The symphonist the English cannot stomach - Slippedisc (2024)

The symphonist the English cannot stomach - Slippedisc (1)

Album Of The Week

norman lebrecht

January 01, 2022

From the Lebrecht Album of the Week:

The hundredth anniversary of a composer’s birth is usually marked by a respectful revival. Not in Malcolm Arnold’s case. The English establishment has always held this remarkable composer at arm’s length, in part because he had the effrontery to win an Oscar (for Bridge on the River Kwai) and in part because of erratic conduct that once landed him in a mental hospital. Musically, there was nothing mad about Malcolm (I knew him a little and liked him a lot)…

Read on here.

And here.

En francais ici.

In Czech here.

In The Critic here.


  • The symphonist the English cannot stomach - Slippedisc (2)christopher storey says:

    January 1, 2022 at 7:05 pm

    Another sad figure in British Music . I do wonder whether the avoidance of his symphonies comes from their not infrequently disturbing character , in complete contrast to his shorter orchestral pieces, the dances in particular . But then, George Lloyd’s serious works are sadly and badly neglected, as are those of Rubbra


  • The symphonist the English cannot stomach - Slippedisc (3)George Kennaway says:

    January 1, 2022 at 7:16 pm

    Sorry, but no. He was a sort of suburban version of Sibelius.


  • The symphonist the English cannot stomach - Slippedisc (4)J Barcelo says:

    January 1, 2022 at 7:57 pm

    Ever since Andrew Penny’s survey of the symphonies came out on Naxos, I’ve been a huge fan, only knowing his music previously from the Scottish and English dances, and then in arrangements for brass band. But don’t blame orchestras for not playing his music. Blame can be laid at the feet of audiences, who are generally uninterested in the unfamiliar and would rather hear the Beethoven 9th or Tchaikovsky 6th for the 100th time than give something new a chance. And orchestra management knows that they must sell tickets and fill those seats to avoid financial ruin. Mahler will do that; Malcolm Arnold won’t. I don’t know what the concert repertoire looks like in London with so many professional orchestras, but I doubt that the symphonies of Arnold, Alwyn, Arnell, Bax, Rubbra, Simpson, Searle, Stanford, Parry, or even Vaughan Williams are all that often played. How often are the Elgar symphonies played these days? Arnold’s music will continue to be known mostly by people like me who buy CDs and are tired of the worn-out, over-played European repertoire. And Happy New Year!


  • The symphonist the English cannot stomach - Slippedisc (8)Ruben Greenberg says:

    January 1, 2022 at 8:27 pm

    He had the misfortune to be of the same generation as the avant-gardists thus not the flavour of the day, especially for critics and pundits. My friend, the composer Gordon Sherwood who earned a living as a beggar, had the same problem; writing tonal music when Boulez was the one that decided who got the money. Yet there was nothing conservative about Malcolm Arnold: bout his music or his ideas.


  • The symphonist the English cannot stomach - Slippedisc (9)MacroV says:

    January 1, 2022 at 9:57 pm

    I don’t know Malcolm Arnold nearly well enough but I’ve always liked the works I’ve heard or played. And he’s pretty decently represented on disc, if Amazon listings are any indication. But he doesn’t seem to have spread much beyond the UK. Maybe some U.S. orchestras could take up his symphonies; in American English music rarely goes beyond Enigma and the Planets.


  • The symphonist the English cannot stomach - Slippedisc (10)Corno di Caccia says:

    January 2, 2022 at 1:11 am

    A very harsh and sad headline. Malcolm Arnold was one of our greatest composers and the neglect of his music is unforgivable, in my opinion. Establishment bias and ignorance lie at the heart of this situation. As a young horn player I had the good fortune to have met Malcolm years ago and found him to be very kind and supportive. It’s high time his music received a thorough re-evaluation.
    The same could be said about many of our composers of the past, however: Arnold Bax, William Alwyn, Edmund Rubbra, Gerald Finzi, Herbert Howells and Ivor Gurney, to name but a few. For me the BBC Proms should champion such music. After all, Arnold was a one time principal trumpet with the London Philharmonic Orchestra and knew how to write exciting and original orchestral music, including much film music, of course. The snobbery that existed during his lifetime because of his success in composing for the big screen was just pathetic. The same did not happen in the case of Walton. Such music should be celebrated.
    I’ll be very interested to see how much attention Vaughan Williams receives in his celebratory year.
    The third-rate music we hear by contemporary composers should be ditched and more concert and radio time given to the greats of the past.


  • The symphonist the English cannot stomach - Slippedisc (11)Steve says:

    January 2, 2022 at 8:29 am

    This is a somewhat exaggerated piece. As well as the 5th Symphony at the Proms, the BBC had a week of programmes dedicated to Arnold in October (to coincide with his birthday). He was featured at the Presteigne and Buxton Festivals as well as at the annual Malcolm Arnold Festival in Northampton. Naxos released a box of his complete symphonies (admittedly recordings which had been released individually earlier). Given that this was during a year when live concerts and recordings were disrupted by Covid, he wasn’t exactly shunned.


  • The symphonist the English cannot stomach - Slippedisc (12)Akutagawa says:

    January 2, 2022 at 8:49 am

    I went to the prom in question last year where they performed the 5th. It was a well constructed, cleverly orchestrated piece with one cracking tune that I was glad to have heard once in my life, in the same way that ornithologists like ticking off rare wading birds. However, even allowing for Covid restrictions, the hall was around 15% full at most. I don’t think that the British musical establishment is banning performances of Arnold as much as the British music-going public isn’t buying tickets to hear him. Perhaps, as you might argue, that’s their loss. But you can’t expect orchestras to keep on programming works that nobody comes to listen to.


    • The symphonist the English cannot stomach - Slippedisc (13)Dave says:

      January 3, 2022 at 11:51 pm

      The concert-going public isn’t going to buy tickets for non-existent concerts; how many times in a normal year do our major orchestras programme Arnold? And it’s not really fair to extrapolate sales during covid to what they might be at other times. In any case, Proms audiences have been brainwashed into favouring gigs by glamour bands, often with mundane content, over much more interesting programmes by less glitzy outfits.


  • The symphonist the English cannot stomach - Slippedisc (14)Paul Johnson says:

    January 2, 2022 at 10:59 am

    Then the “establishment” should be thoroughly ashamed. What did the “establishment” ever create?


  • The symphonist the English cannot stomach - Slippedisc (15)John Borstlap says:

    January 2, 2022 at 11:43 am

    The relative neglect by the establishment is explained by Arnold’s aesthetic: it’s decidedly tonal and closer to Shostakovich and Sibelius than to the British modernism of the sixties and later.

    Here is his 9th:

    Such type of music is entirely normal and legitimate, although I think there is much in this 9th to complain about – but that is another matter.

    Tonal music has never completely been pushed away in the UK, today there is, for example, David Matthews (brother of Colin), and younger composers exploring this territory, as so many younger composers in the USA and France.


    • The symphonist the English cannot stomach - Slippedisc (16)Anthony Sanderson says:

      January 2, 2022 at 6:29 pm

      The BBC Music Magazine recently ran a front cover entitled Malcolm Arnold the British Shostakovich.


      • The symphonist the English cannot stomach - Slippedisc (17)John Borstlap says:

        January 3, 2022 at 4:17 pm



  • The symphonist the English cannot stomach - Slippedisc (18)Corno di Caccia says:

    January 2, 2022 at 12:14 pm

    It is very true to note that the BBC honoured Malcolm Arnold’s centenary week with featuring him as Composer of the Week at the time and Sakari Oramo’s performance of the fifth symphony at the 2021 Proms was a welcome addition. There was also a very interesting programme called ‘The Tortured Composer’ aired on Radio as well. It must also be a contributory factor that the conductors who championed the music of our forgotten composers like Boult, Handley, Groves, and Hickox, are all no longer with us and the modern British conductors, who are thin on the ground anyway, just don’t seem interested. Even Mark Elder has a few serious holes in his British music repertoire CV.
    As for the Establishment, they are, it would appear, solely occupied with preserving themselves. Nothing new there.
    Arnold’s symphonies are well worth investing time to listen them thoroughly. As mentioned already, Andrew Penny’s Naxos set is excellent way to start. One of the good things about the Lockdown was having the time to dig out such recordings and play them. There is still much to discover if you can be bothered.


  • The symphonist the English cannot stomach - Slippedisc (19)Una says:

    January 2, 2022 at 1:49 pm

    At least the Proms this summer, relying on talented and often overlooked British performers and composers, suddenly woke up to him being a fine yet underestimated and undervalued English composer. I certainly enjoyed songs of his I did in recitals. If only he and we were all perfect in this life, but we’re not!


  • The symphonist the English cannot stomach - Slippedisc (20)Lindsay Wallace says:

    January 2, 2022 at 1:56 pm

    As Sir Thomas Beecham said in 1928 “English music today is in that extraordinary state of perpetual promise. It is perhaps the nearest approach to perpetual motion we have, for it goes on promising & promising & has done so for three hundred years. In fact, it might be said to be one gigantic promissory note.” Seriously though, if it wasn’t for complaining that his national music is neglected, which it patently isn’t, what would your average English music lover find to say about it!


    • The symphonist the English cannot stomach - Slippedisc (21)Paul Carlile says:

      January 2, 2022 at 3:13 pm

      Very true. I’m with Sir Thomas on this one!


  • The symphonist the English cannot stomach - Slippedisc (22)Miv Tucker says:

    January 2, 2022 at 3:07 pm

    Older readers may remember that in the days before R3 broadcast round the clock, they would play some introductory music just before the 7am time signal and the start of programmes, and for a while in the 70s they used one of Arnold’s English Dances (can’t remember which one), a very nostalgic, elegiac piece.
    And even older readers might remember that another of his English Dances was used as the theme for Granada’s long-running What the Papers Say.


  • The symphonist the English cannot stomach - Slippedisc (23)msc says:

    January 2, 2022 at 6:38 pm

    The attention to his symphonies should not distract people from his concertos, excellent chamber music (I don’t know when I last heard any that I was not playing), and band music. All need more attention.
    As everyone else is saying, neglect of Arnold is simply because of fashion and snobbery.


  • The symphonist the English cannot stomach - Slippedisc (24)Cynical Bystander says:

    January 2, 2022 at 7:10 pm

    I can remember a time not too long ago relatively speaking when Mahler struggled, posthumously, to get a hearing. The ‘Establishment’ has turned a deaf ear to more than just Malcolm Arnold.


    • The symphonist the English cannot stomach - Slippedisc (25)John Borstlap says:

      January 3, 2022 at 4:21 pm

      In the orchestral world, the ‘establishment’ consists of management types, much more concerned with budgets and audience attendance than program content. They are hired for these things, so it is understandable that it is so conservative. The input of conductors into programming is, contrary to what you would expect, quite limited.


  • The symphonist the English cannot stomach - Slippedisc (26)Corno di Caccia says:

    January 2, 2022 at 10:20 pm

    Tommy Beecham also said that the british don’t really understand music but they love the noise it makes. Somehow, I think that’s still the case.
    We have to educate more and when you look at the current crop of conductors (although Sakari Oramo is clearly a fan of Arnold’s music), not to mention the Radio 3 presenters who fall short of any real knowledge about music, in general, and Classic FMs reliance on playing the same old, same old, things will never improve. The BBC constantly sells classical music short when you compare what was broadcast regularly in the 1960s and 1970s. There were, at its inception, high hopes that BBC 4 would fill a gap. However all you get on that are endless repeats of Top of the Pops from decades ago who nobody is interested in anymore. I was hoping that Tony Palmer’s excellent film on Malcolm Arnold would be repeated, only to be sadly disappointed again. I would recommend finding a YouTube clip of Andrew Davis conducting the BBCSO in Arnold’s music from the film The Sound Barrier. It’s played superbly, and the smile on Malcolm Arnold’s face – quite obviously moved to tears – and the reception from the audience is extremely moving. This man’s music deserves to be heard.


  • The symphonist the English cannot stomach - Slippedisc (27)Ian Cole says:

    January 2, 2022 at 11:41 pm

    The institutions that do support Malcolm Arnold are our various Music Colleges which hopefully will ensure he is not forgotten by future generations. In November I had the pleasure of attending a Gala Celebration concert at the Royal Birmingham Conservatoire which was a combination of works performed by students, including the Fantasy for Band, Ukrainian Variations and the Clarinet And Oboe Sonatinas. The concert closed with Margaret Fingerhut and Peter Fisher playing items from their recent disc, including the first Violin Sonata. Norman has, quite rightly in my view, chosen it as his Album of the Week and I for one would thoroughly endorse his recommendation.


  • The symphonist the English cannot stomach - Slippedisc (28)Robert Roy says:

    January 3, 2022 at 12:03 am

    ‘Mental Hospital?!’

    Maybe it’s a bit much to expect 21st Century attitudes but at least get out of the 19thC!


    • The symphonist the English cannot stomach - Slippedisc (29)John Borstlap says:

      January 3, 2022 at 4:26 pm

      Yes, all that awful music, with all of those so-called classics which are mainly boring, as if we still live around 1800 and the whole age that followed it. When I’m forced again to attend a classical concert, you sit there in a beautiful modern hall and what do they play? Totally uninteresting stuff from 100 years ago or older like Mahler, Beethoven, even Mozart, a guy form even longer ago. How often do you get Boulez, or other 20C classics like Xenakis?! Or Berio, or (my particular treat) Lachenmann? The latter one is also very funny, what you cannot get with those old farts!



  • The symphonist the English cannot stomach - Slippedisc (30)christopher storey says:

    January 3, 2022 at 4:05 pm

    What is wrong with the description Mental Hospital ? They were not called that in the 19th century, but had far less savoury terms applied to them . Are we to leave those who have the misfortune to suffer mental illness to fend for themselves? It is thanks to the courage of people like Malcolm Arnold that we are now able to discuss this very important issue openly


  • The symphonist the English cannot stomach - Slippedisc (31)David A. Boxwell says:

    January 3, 2022 at 8:57 pm

    Arnold’s “Carnival of Animals” is much, much funnier than Saint-Saens’.



    • News

      Exclusive: A case of revenge p*rn

      norman lebrecht

      May 24, 2024

      We understand that the Houston Symphony has suspended…

    • Orchestras

      Breaking: NY Phil oboe sues for $100m

      norman lebrecht

      May 23, 2024

      Liang Wang, suspended principal oboe of the New…

    • RIP

      Vienna Philharmonic mourns a concertmaster

      norman lebrecht

      May 24, 2024

      We have received confirmation of the death on…

    • News

      Baby for Benedetti

      norman lebrecht

      May 23, 2024

      We understand that the violinist Nicola Benedetti, director…

    The symphonist the English cannot stomach - Slippedisc (2024)


    What are the four movements of a symphony? ›

    A symphony is made up of four sections called movements. Each movement follows its own structure or format. The first uses a quick tempo and follows sonata-allegro form; the second is slower and more lyrical; the third is a minuet or scherzo and the final movement often uses sonata-allegro form.

    Who is often called the father of symphony? ›

    Franz Joseph Haydn was called the father of the symphony because he contributed so much to this genre of music. Haydn composed over 100 symphonies. Haydn also composed and made famous chamber music, which evolved into symphonic music. Haydn was noted for his piano trios, with piano, cello and violin.

    What is the most performed symphony? ›

    • Brahms's First. Johannes Brahms didn't complete his Symphony No. ...
    • Beethoven's Fifth. The four opening notes of Ludwig van Beethoven's symphony, which the composer likened to fate knocking at the door, are arguably the most famous in all of music. ...
    • Beethoven's Seventh. ...
    • Brahms's Second. ...
    • Brahms's Fourth.

    How long does a symphony last? ›

    A symphony is a big piece in several ways. Though it's divided into separate parts (usually, four individual movements), a typical Classical Period symphony can last between 25 and 35 minutes.

    What was Haydn's nickname and why? ›

    For years the nickname 'Papa Haydn' has characterized the composer. Used by his own musicians and others as a tribute of affection and respect, the expression increasingly took on misleading connotations, and came to signify a benevolent but bewigged and old-fashioned classic.

    What is Haydn's most famous piece? ›

    Nelson Mass. Officially titled Missa in angustiis, or 'Mass for troubled times', Haydn's Nelson Mass has been described by his biographer H.C. Robbins Landon as “arguably Haydn's greatest single composition.” What high praise.

    What happened to Haydn's head after his death? ›

    The skull was taken from the Musikverein and delivered by the Russians to Prince Esterhazy in Eisenstadt. There followed, 145 years after his death, a full funeral procession through the streets of Eisenstadt for the now long-dead composer.

    What is considered the best symphony ever written? ›

    The best symphonies of all time
    • 7) Berlioz – Symphonie Fantastique (1830)
    • 6) Brahms – Symphony No. 4 (1885)
    • 5) Mahler – Symphony No. 2 (1894 rev. 1903)
    • 4) Mahler – Symphony No. 9 (1909)
    • 3) Mozart – Symphony No. 41 (1788)
    • 2) Beethoven – Symphony No. 9 (1824)
    • 1) Beethoven - Symphony No. 3 (1803)
    Mar 19, 2024

    What is the greatest piece of music ever written? ›

    • Der Ring des Nibelungen (The Ring of the Nibelung), WWV 86. ...
    • 2446 Ludwig van Beethoven Symphony 1824 Play.
    • Mass in B Minor. ...
    • Symphony No. ...
    • Piano Concerto No. ...
    • The Art of Fugue (Die Kunst der Fuge), BWV 1080. ...
    • Tristan und Isolde (Tristan and Isolde), WWV 90. 527 Richard Wagner Opera 1859 Play.
    • Piano Concerto No. 20 in D Minor, K.

    Is it normal to cry at a symphony? ›

    Feeling like crying—an experience ranging from feeling like one might cry, such as getting a lump in the throat or having tears welling up, to actually crying—is a common response to the arts in general (Nusbaum & Silvia, 2014; Pelowski, 2015; Trimble, 2012) and to music in particular.

    Where is the best place to sit for a symphony? ›

    The most balanced sound in the hall is usually in the center of the hall. If you are looking for the purest sound, this area would be a great place to look! If you are looking for a seat closer to the stage, some parts of the orchestra will be more prominent.

    What is the hardest instrument to play in a symphony? ›

    I'm playing one of the hardest instruments in the world”.
    1. Violin. The violin is a commonly learnt instrument, so you may be surprised to see this lying at the top of this list! ...
    2. Bagpipes. The bagpipes rank high in this list for their challenging physical demands. ...
    3. French horn. ...
    4. Hammond organ. ...
    5. Accordion.
    Jan 11, 2023

    What are the 4 groups of the symphony orchestra? ›

    Orchestra Instrument Families: Strings, Woodwinds, Brass, Percussion | Oregon Symphony.

    What is the 4 movement work played by orchestras in the classical period? ›

    To provide context, the typical symphony in the Classical Period was comprised of four movements, I. Allegro; III. Minuet with Trio in the same key as the first movement; and IV. Allegro or Presto, also in the key of the first movement.

    What is a 4 movement classic genre for orchestra? ›

    Symphony – Large-scale composition, typically for an orchestra and often in four movements.

    What was the most common four movement plan for the classical symphony? ›

    The most typical four-movement plan is F—S—minuet—F. (Instead of either a conventional minuet-finale or a fast-finale after the slow movement, one had both.) Occasionally, the minuet was placed in second-movement position. There are currently two points of view with regard to the origin of the four-movement symphony.

    Top Articles
    Latest Posts
    Article information

    Author: Catherine Tremblay

    Last Updated:

    Views: 6039

    Rating: 4.7 / 5 (47 voted)

    Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

    Author information

    Name: Catherine Tremblay

    Birthday: 1999-09-23

    Address: Suite 461 73643 Sherril Loaf, Dickinsonland, AZ 47941-2379

    Phone: +2678139151039

    Job: International Administration Supervisor

    Hobby: Dowsing, Snowboarding, Rowing, Beekeeping, Calligraphy, Shooting, Air sports

    Introduction: My name is Catherine Tremblay, I am a precious, perfect, tasty, enthusiastic, inexpensive, vast, kind person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.